2023 Report on International Religious Freedom: Philippines

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The constitution provides for the free exercise of religion and religious worship and prohibits the establishment of a state religion. The constitution provides for the separation of religion and state, and religious groups are required to register to obtain tax-exempt status.

As part of the government’s campaign against groups pursuing violent opposition to the state, particularly the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People’s Army (CPP-NPA), the government pursued court cases against some religious workers who were identified by the government as communist members or sympathizers. In March, a regional court convicted a financial official of the Rural Missionaries of the Philippines (RMP) of terrorist financing. Cases against others charged in 2022, including four Catholic nuns, remained pending. In October, authorities arrested drag performer Pura Luka Vega under the section of the criminal code that prohibits performances that “offend any race or religion.” In August, Senator Robin Padilla, a Muslim, urged the Senate to investigate a shooting earlier that month at a police station allegedly connected to discrimination and harassment against Muslims; the incident resulted in the death of a police officer and the serious wounding of another. The House of Representatives in January overwhelmingly approved the Magna Carta of Religious Freedom Act which specifies the rights of individuals related to religious beliefs as well as punishment of those who contravene such rights. Humanists, atheists, Muslims, and other religious minorities expressed continuing concern that the bill favored Christians and did not offer equal protections of the right to not believe in any form of religion. The Senate held a hearing on the legislation in August, and it remained pending at year’s end. The Commission on Human Rights reported in 2021 that limited budget resources and overcrowding led to problems providing religious accommodation for prison inmates, including providing halal food for Muslims.

In December, the ISIS-affiliated Dawlah Islamiya terrorist group detonated a bomb during a Catholic Mass at Mindanao State University, killing four persons and injuring more than 50 others. Social media comments denigrating the beliefs or practices of Muslims continued to appear online during the year, and public figures such as Senator Padilla stated that Muslims continue to face discrimination and human rights abuses in the country. In February, the Catholic Bishops Conference of the Philippines (CBCP) reported the “red tagging” (public labeling of individuals as being affiliated with insurgent, terrorist, or separatist groups) of Bishop of San Carlos Gerardo Alminaza, known for his advocacy of talks between the government and the CPP-NPA.

Embassy officers discussed religious freedom issues, including the red tagging and indictment of members of religious groups, with officials from the Commission on Human Rights and the Presidential Human Rights Committee. Embassy officers also met with representatives of the CBCP and the National Council of Churches of the Philippines to discuss the status of religious freedom in the country as well as challenges faced by church workers. The embassy encouraged local governments in the Lanao region of the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region of Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) to invest in community learning facilities that served as venues for cooperation and dialogue, including on religious freedom.

The U.S. government estimates the total population at 116.4 million (midyear 2023). According to the 2015 census conducted by the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA), 79.5 percent of the population is Roman Catholic and 9 percent belongs to other Christian groups, including Seventh-day Adventists, the United Church of Christ in the Philippines (UCCP), United Methodists, the Episcopal Church in the Philippines, the Bible Baptist Church, other Protestant churches, Jehovah’s Witnesses, and The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Other Christian groups include locally established churches such as the Iglesia ni Cristo (Church of Christ), the Philippine Independent Church (Aglipayan or IFI), Members Church of God International, The Kingdom of Jesus Christ, and The Name Above Every Name. Approximately 6 percent of the population is Muslim, according to the PSA, while the National Commission for Muslim Filipinos (NCMF), a government agency, estimates the number is 10 to 11 percent. The NCMF attributes its higher estimate to several factors, including the reluctance of Muslims to register officially with the civil registrar office or to participate in the formal survey, the community’s transience due to internal movement for work, and what the NCMF states is the national government’s failure to thoroughly survey Muslim areas and communities. According to the PSA, approximately 4 percent of those surveyed in the 2015 census did not report a religious affiliation or belonged to other faiths, such as animism or Indigenous syncretic faiths.

Most Muslims are members of various ethnic minority groups and reside in Mindanao and nearby islands in the south. While a majority of the population in Mindanao Province is Christian, Muslims constitute a majority of the BARMM’s population. Although most are practitioners of Sunni Islam, a small minority of Shia Muslims live in the region, mostly in the provinces of Lanao del Sur and Zamboanga del Sur in Mindanao. An increasing number of Muslims are migrating to the urban centers of Manila, Baguio, Dumaguete, Cagayan de Oro, Iligan, Cotabato, and Davao.

Indigenous groups in Mindanao are mostly located in geographically isolated areas. The National Commission on Indigenous Peoples in 2022 reported 10.9 million Indigenous persons in Mindanao who primarily belong to various Christian groups, with a small percentage who are Muslim.

 

LEGAL FRAMEWORK

The constitution provides for the free exercise of religion and religious worship and prohibits the establishment of a state religion. No religious test is required for the exercise of civil or political rights. The constitution provides for the separation of religion and state. The law treats intentional attacks directed against religiously affiliated buildings or facilities as war crimes or crimes against international humanitarian law. The law forbids public officials from interrupting religious worship as well as any person from “notoriously” offending religious feelings during such services or in a place of worship.

The law requires organized religious groups to register with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) to establish tax-exempt status. Religious groups must submit their articles of faith and bylaws to the SEC to register as religious corporations. The SEC requires religious corporations to submit annual financial statements. The law does not specify penalties for failure to register with the SEC. To register as a nonstock, nonprofit organization, religious groups must meet the basic requirements for corporate registration with the BIR and request a tax exemption from the BIR. The basic requirements for registration include a name verification of the religious corporation, articles of incorporation and bylaws, the name of a director, list of members, and a list of financial contributors. The BIR provides tax exemptions to established religious corporations that are then reviewed for renewal every three years. The BIR may fine religious corporations for the late filing of registrations or for failing to submit registration datasheets and financial statements.

The government permits religious instruction in public schools with written parental consent, provided there is no cost to the government. Based on a traditional policy of promoting moral education, local public schools give religious groups the opportunity to teach moral values and general understanding of a specific religion during school hours. Attendance is not mandatory; parents must express in writing a desire for their child to attend religious instruction for a specific denomination, and the various groups share classroom space. Students who do not attend religious instruction because no class was offered in their denomination, or because their parents did not express a desire that they do so, receive normal supervised class time. The government also allows the distribution of religious literature in public schools. The law mandates that the government address religious issues and consult recognized experts on Filipino Muslim beliefs, as well as the history, culture, and identity of Indigenous peoples, when formulating the national history curriculum.

By law, public schools must protect the religious rights of all students. Muslim girls may wear the hijab and are not required to wear shorts during physical education classes.

The government recognizes sharia in all parts of the country through a presidential decree. Sharia courts are organized into five sharia districts, all located in the south of the country; Muslims residing in other areas must travel to these districts to pursue an action in a sharia court. Sharia courts handle only cases relating to personal status laws affecting family relations and property for Muslims and do not handle criminal cases. The state court system hears cases involving Muslims and non-Muslims, and national laws apply in those cases.

The BARMM is a Muslim-led region established by the central government in 2019, with jurisdiction over five provinces and three major noncontiguous cities. The Bangsamoro Organic Law provides the framework for the transition to greater autonomy for the area’s majority Muslim population; the transition completion date is set for 2025.

The NCMF’s Bureau of Pilgrimage and Endowment is responsible for administering logistics for the Hajj, such as obtaining flight schedules, administering vaccines, coordinating with the Department of Foreign Affairs to process Hajj passports, filing Hajj visa applications at the Saudi Arabia embassy, and conducting predeparture orientations for pilgrims. The NCMF also administers the awqaf (an endowment for the upkeep of Islamic properties and institutions) and continues to oversee the establishment and maintenance of Islamic centers and other projects.

The country is a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

GOVERNMENT PRACTICES

On March 16, a trial court in Iligan City convicted a financial official from the RMP of being an accessory to terrorist financing. The previous August, the Department of Justice charged 16 members of the RMP, including four Catholic nuns, with providing funds to the armed wing of the CPP-NPA. Those cases remained pending at year’s end.

In August, Hermogenes Esperon, National Security Adviser during the previous Rodrigo Duterte administration, requested a review of a lower court decision acquitting 10 human rights defenders of perjury charges filed by Esperon in 2019. Among those charged were Father Wilfredo Ruazol of the Philippine Independent Church and Sister Elenita Belardo of the RMP. Human rights groups and observers described the case as reprisal against those individuals for seeking legal protection from the Supreme Court from threats and harassment by government officials against human rights defenders during the Duterte administration.

There were continued instances of red tagging – the public labeling of human rights advocates, unions, religious groups, academics, and media organizations as fronts for or clandestine members of insurgent and political groups. These actions, put them at risk of intimidation and violence. Some red tagging incidents targeted members of religious groups and religious organizations.

In October, Manila police arrested drag performer Pura Luka Vega under the section of the criminal code that prohibits “indecent or immoral plays, scenes, acts or shows” that “offend any race or religion.” In a July video, Bega performed a version of the Lord’s Prayer dressed in clothing that was deemed to resemble that of Jesus Christ. Several religious groups condemned the performance and some municipal leaders made statements that Vega was not welcome in their jurisdictions.

In August, Senator Padilla urged the Senate to investigate a shooting incident earlier that month at the Taguig City police station that resulted in the death of a police officer and the serious wounding of another. The incident stemmed from an altercation between police officers, one of whom was Muslim, who was unknowingly served a pork dish at the police station. The Muslim police officer sent a letter to Padilla noting that the incident followed previous instances of discrimination and harassment aimed at Muslims. Padilla also urged the Senate to investigate instances of violation of Islamic dietary laws in prisons.

The Commission on Human Rights, which has a constitutional mandate to visit and inspect prisons and detention facilities nationwide, reported in September that limited budget resources provided by the government, combined with the high crowding rate of the majority of prisons and detention centers, led to problems in complying with the principles of religious freedom and religious accommodation for inmates. The commission noted there was limited availability of halal food options for Muslim inmates.

In January, the House of Representatives overwhelmingly approved the Magna Carta of Religious Freedom Act, passing the legislation on for further action by the Senate. At year’s end the bill remained pending in the Senate, which held committee hearings on the legislation in August. If passed by the Senate without change, the law would enumerate the rights of every person to propagate one’s religious beliefs and disseminate religious publications and the rights to religious worship and ceremonies, organizational independence, and freedom against discrimination in employment. It would criminalize compelling a person, by means of force, threat, intimidation, or punishment, to choose or not to choose a specific religion; obstructing, hindering, or preventing the flow of access to religious information; and defaming, harassing, or humiliating a person because of his or her religious beliefs. Some Humanist, atheist, Muslim, and other religious minority groups expressed continued concern that the legislation would favor Christians and not offer equal protection to nonreligious individuals. The CBCP, the Philippines for Jesus Movement, and the Muslim group Philippine Ulama Congress Organization expressed support for the bill but noted it should highlight the constitutional provision requiring the separation of church and state. These groups stated that the employment discrimination provision of the law should not apply to religious organizations and requested an amendment protecting their right to autonomy over hiring practices.

In September, the executive secretary of the CBCP Commission on Public Affairs, Father Jerome Secilliano, expressed opposition to proposed legislation that would legalize divorce, saying it would cause more harm than good to Filipino families. Reflecting what Freedom House Country Coordinator Aileen Almora stated was the strong influence of the Catholic Church on the legislature, the bill was not voted out of committee in the House, and at year’s end was pending a second reading in the Senate.

The Department of Education continued to support its Arabic Language and Islamic Values Education (ALIVE) program for Muslim students in private madrassahs and public elementary schools with a Muslim student population of 10 percent or more. For the 2022-23 school year, 4,122 public elementary schools administered the voluntary ALIVE program for 153,605 students. The program’s stated aim is to integrate madrassahs into the public education system while preserving Islamic education for Muslims.

Private madrassahs continued to have the option of registering with the NCMF or the Department of Education (DepEd), both, or neither. DepEd-accredited madrassahs continued to receive government funding and teacher training and followed the standardized DepEd curriculum. The DepEd Office of Madrassah Education managed local and international financial assistance on behalf of the private madrassah system. By law, only registered schools or madrassahs could receive financial assistance from the government. There were 12 private madrassahs registered with the DepEd during the 2022-23 school year, a slight increase from 11 in 2021-22. Some private madrassahs chose to remain unregistered rather than allow government oversight, according to DepEd representatives.

Madrassahs registered by the Department of Education followed the official Standard Madrassah Curriculum and received funding for classrooms, facilities, and educators who taught the Revised Basic Education Curriculum. The overall funding for, and attendance at, private madrassahs continued to decrease from 2021 to 2022 due to the implementation of the Bangsamoro Organic Law, which created the BARMM and a separate BARMM budget for the region’s education. During the year, the total madrassah education budget was 359.5 million pesos ($6.4 million), of which the Department of Education provided 6.7 million pesos ($121,000) to 12 private madrassahs.

At year’s end, there were 11 Muslims in the 312-member House of Representatives and one Muslim in the 24-member Senate, unchanged from the previous year. Muslim individuals served as presidential adviser on Muslim Affairs, Human Rights Commissioner, and head of the NCMF.

Muslim officials continued to report that while Muslim prisoners were allowed to engage in religious observances, Roman Catholic masses were often broadcast by loudspeaker to the entire prison population.

Social media comments denigrating the beliefs or practices of Muslims continued to appear online during the year. Public figures such as Senator Padilla stated Muslims continued to face discrimination and human rights abuses in the country, although there were no statistics available concerning number of incidents. Adventist legal counsel Gizelle Lou Cabahug-Fugoso expressed concerns about the difficulties Adventist Church members have faced in balancing the requirement to attend to education or employment obligations on Saturday, which Adventists consider the biblical Sabbath.

Representatives of both the CBCP and the National Council of Churches of the Philippines stated that instances of red tagging against church leaders were politically motivated.

ISIS, through one of its affiliated organizations, Dawlah Islamiyah, claimed responsibility for detonating a bomb December 3 at Mindanao State University in Marawi during a Catholic Mass that killed four persons and injured more than 50 others. According to Armed Forces Chief Romeo Brawner, the government suspected the bombing was in retaliation for the killing of 21 members of Dawlah Islamiyah between June and the beginning of December 2023 by government security forces.

Government agencies mandated to document and monitor cases of abuse and restriction of religious freedom, such as the Commission on Human Rights and the Presidential Human Rights Committee, reported they did not receive any cases regarding abuses of religious freedom during the year. An NGO based in Mindanao said it received informal reports of discrimination against Muslims, but that these were not formally conveyed to local officials.

In February, producers of the Batang Quiapo television series aired by the FPJ network apologized to the Muslim community after Muslim representative Ziaur Alonto Adiong said the portrayal of its Muslim characters was “discriminatory, harmful, and derogatory.” Adiong stated the creators of shows should consider the impact their work would have on society and ensure they not contribute to continuing incidents of hate speech and extremism.

The CBCP reported the red tagging of Catholic Bishop of San Carlos Gerardo Alminaza in February. The Sonshine Media Network International (SMNI) labeled Alminza as a “mouthpiece” of the CPP. Alminaza is known for his peace advocacy which included proposing peace talks between the central government and the CPP-NDF. The CBCP stated the incident showed the inherent danger of the practice of red tagging being used against public dissent and opposition, adding that any church leader engaged in human rights work was at risk of being designated as a terrorist under the 2020 Antiterrorism Act if the government believed allegations made by private media groups. Sources stated the (SMNI) did not have the same power and influence with national government officials as under the previous Duterte administration, yet it retained significant influence over provincial and local government officials in many areas of the country.

Embassy officers met with the Commission on Human Rights and the Presidential Human Rights Committee to discuss religious freedom problems, including the red tagging and indictment of members of religious groups, particularly Catholic priests and nuns and Protestant pastors, and discrimination against Muslims.

In August, the embassy observed the court proceeding of 10 human rights defenders charged with perjury in 2019 by former National Security Adviser Esperon. The group included a member of the clergy and a Catholic sister.

The embassy met separately with representatives of the CBCP and the National Council of Churches of the Philippines to discuss the status of religious freedom in the country as well as difficulties faced by church workers.

The embassy encouraged local governments in the Lanao region of the BARMM to invest in community learning facilities that could serve as venues for community dialogue, including on religious freedom. The embassy also partnered with the national penal system to produce a “peace education manual” that draws on religious tolerance concepts and best practices to help prison authorities recognize and address religious extremism among convicted prisoners.

The embassy continued to use online platforms and virtual engagement to emphasize strong U.S. support for religious freedom and the protection of civil liberties for persons of all faiths, including highlighting subjects such as the freedom to worship and the importance of religious tolerance.